On January 14, 2016, Father John Misty performed "Holy Shit" on "The Late Show with Stephen Colbert," promoting his critically acclaimed album "I Love You, Honeybear," which was released in February 2015. This live performance came during a pivotal moment in his career when he was gaining significant attention for his unique blend of folk, rock, and sharp lyricism. "I Love You, Honeybear" was not just well-received by fans but also praised by critics, further solidifying his reputation as a prominent voice in contemporary music. Notably, the album reflects themes of love and disillusionment, and the evocative nature of "Holy Shit" aligned perfectly with his satirical and introspective style. This performance, characterized by its emotional intensity and engaging stage presence, epitomizes the artistic evolution of Josh Tillman—Father John Misty’s real name—as he embraced his role as a cultural commentator during this era.