In January 2009, when The Walkmen performed "In the New Year" on "Late Night With Conan O'Brien," they were in the midst of promoting their album, "You & Me," which had been released in September 2008. This album marked a significant point in their career, featuring a more mature sound and exploration of themes that resonated with both critics and fans. "You & Me" included a blend of intricate melodies and poignant lyrics, establishing the band as key players in the indie rock scene of the time. The live performance showcased their dynamic stage presence and ability to translate their studio sound effectively in a live setting. Notably, the song "In the New Year" became emblematic of their sound during this period, highlighting their continued evolution and commitment to crafting memorable music.