In April 2008, when The New Pornographers performed "The Bleeding Heart Show" at the Phoenix Concert Theatre in Toronto, they were riding the wave of success from their album *Challengers*, which had come out in 2007. This album marked a significant moment for the band, showcasing their signature blend of catchy melodies and intricate harmonies, alongside a slightly more reflective lyrical approach. It's a notable time in their career as they were beginning to gain broader recognition, expanding their audience beyond indie music enthusiasts. The live energy captured in this recording reflects the band's dynamic stage presence, a hallmark of their performances. Fun fact: "The Bleeding Heart Show" itself is a fan favorite, celebrated for its anthemic chorus and relatable themes of love and loss. This concert in Toronto accentuated their commitment to engaging with fans, creating an unforgettable atmosphere during this noteworthy period in their journey.