In February 2008, The Walkmen were riding high on the waves of their critically acclaimed album *Pussy Cats* which was released just a few months earlier, in November 2006. This album, a rather quirky collaboration with the legendary producer Father John Misty, showcased their distinctive lo-fi rock sound infused with a raw, nostalgic vibe. Their live performance of “If Only It Were True” at The Independent in San Francisco gives fans a glimpse of their energetic stage presence during this vibrant era. Interestingly, this performance came just prior to the release of *You & Me* in 2008, which would further cement their place in the indie rock scene. A notable moment from this recording is frontman Hamilton Leithauser's passionate delivery, which highlights not only his vocal prowess but also the emotional depth they’ve become known for. Fans likely found a touching connection with their music that night, as The Walkmen were on the brink of crafting songs that would resonate deeply in indie circles.