Before their electrifying live performance of "On the Water" at the Brooklyn Masonic Temple in December 2008, The Walkmen had released their album *You & Me* earlier that same year. This album marked a poignant moment in their evolution, showcasing a more introspective sound while maintaining their signature indie rock vibe. The *You & Me* tracks often reflected themes of nostalgia and personal introspection, which resonated deeply with fans. The live recording captures not just the raw energy of the band but also a deep emotional connection with their audience, a hallmark of The Walkmen’s performances. Interestingly, the venue itself, a former Masonic lodge, adds a unique atmosphere, merging the band's indie aesthetic with historic charm. It's a fitting backdrop for the soaring, evocative sound of “On the Water,” which explores themes of distance and longing—a poignant touchpoint that echoes throughout their career.