In July 2009, when The Walkmen delivered their spirited performance at Mr. Smalls Theatre, they were riding a wave of momentum following their album *You & Me*, released the previous year. This album is often seen as a pivotal moment in their career, showcasing a mature sound while retaining the band’s characteristic energy. Interestingly, *You & Me* was well-received both critically and commercially, marking a significant evolution in their style that emphasized introspective lyrics and complex melodies. During the live recording of "In the New Year," fans likely felt the palpable energy that The Walkmen brought to their performances, as the song perfectly encapsulates themes of hope and renewal, reflecting their growing artistic maturity. This energetic yet reflective phase resonated with their audience, and moments like these live recordings help capture the band’s dynamic connection with fans.