On February 5, 2013, Yo La Tengo performed a live recording of "Can't Forget" at the Barrymore Theater in Madison, Wisconsin. At this time, the band was promoting their album "Fade," which had been released in January 2013, marking an exciting phase in their career. "Fade" was noted for its more subdued sound, focusing on atmosphere and introspection, a departure from their earlier works. This concert featured a diverse setlist that included both mellow and more energetic songs, showcasing the band's versatility and ability to engage different moods. Interestingly, the show consisted of two sets and two encores, highlighting the band's commitment to providing a rich live experience for their audience. This attention to performance is a hallmark of Yo La Tengo's career, reflecting their long-standing reputation for dynamic live presentations and deep connection with fans during concerts.