In July 2009, when Umphrey's McGee performed "Syncopated Strangers," the band was in the midst of a prolific period, having released their album "Mantis" just months earlier in February 2009. "Mantis" showcased a mature sound with a blend of progressive rock and jazz influences and included intricate compositions, reflecting the band's evolution. The live performance of "Syncopated Strangers" highlights their improvisational prowess, a hallmark of their shows, and illustrates the band's interactive relationship with their audience. By this time, Umphrey's McGee had established a robust following and was known for their dynamic live shows, incorporating fan-favorite tracks and extensive jamming. This performance underscores their reputation as a leading band in the jam band scene, where they uniquely combine structured songs and spontaneous improvisation.